Yeah you're right, but I still think it's doable. I'm sure they could find ways to make it work: playing with the tank's range, tweaking the way bosses' mechanics work, I don't know.
Let's look at it from a different angle, how can someone exploit the fact that he is a range tank ?
You could completely avoid bosses' auto attacks. But is there any ? So far all we are seeing is telegraphs. And again simple mechanic adjustments could fix this. ( like all bosses have mini-range attacks that are considered melee. I think It'd be dumb honestly, cause the 'range' aspect of the tank would really just be cosmetic at that point tough.. )
I'm really having a hard time figuring this out, I guess that's why I'm terribad at tanking and I prefer healing...
The forums have been archived!
Please visit our Discord server: https://discord.gg/grievance
A melee healing class.
- Shadowborn
- Member 7 years
- Posts: 1806
- Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2011 9:41 am
Re: A melee healing class.
Our spirit is stronger than you know demon! If we are to fall, then so be it! At least now... we are free!
-Thrall, at the battle of Mount Hyjal.

-Thrall, at the battle of Mount Hyjal.

Re: A melee healing class.
Ranged DPS/Tank vs Ranged DPS/Ranged Tank.
When engineers tank, they tank melee. When they DPS, they are ranged DPS.
What would you think about that?
When engineers tank, they tank melee. When they DPS, they are ranged DPS.
What would you think about that?
- Shadowborn
- Member 7 years
- Posts: 1806
- Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2011 9:41 am
Re: A melee healing class.
Yeah that would be the obvious solution, but the 'ranged tank' speculation came form the idea that the warrior would be the standard mitigation tank, the stalker would be the avoidance/evasion tank and the final tanking class would introduce some kind of new mechanics.Tsetzuko wrote:Ranged DPS/Tank vs Ranged DPS/Ranged Tank.
When engineers tank, they tank melee. When they DPS, they are ranged DPS.
What would you think about that?
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Our spirit is stronger than you know demon! If we are to fall, then so be it! At least now... we are free!
-Thrall, at the battle of Mount Hyjal.

-Thrall, at the battle of Mount Hyjal.

- TheDutchess
- new member
- Posts: 30
- Joined: Mon Jul 29, 2013 6:19 am
Re: A melee healing class.
If the last class is an 'engineer', i could also imagine ranged tanking by them having to throw up stuff near the boss and tanking that way. So basically stay at range yourself, but throw up robots and stuff that are linked with you that are near the boss.
In raids i'd imagine they make sure you need at least one tank of each class. Would think the ranged tank very good at picking up adds for instance.
(as for pvp, dunno and tbh don't really care
)
In raids i'd imagine they make sure you need at least one tank of each class. Would think the ranged tank very good at picking up adds for instance.
(as for pvp, dunno and tbh don't really care


- Shadowborn
- Member 7 years
- Posts: 1806
- Joined: Thu Jan 27, 2011 9:41 am
Re: A melee healing class.
I like that idea, but I think it'd be a nightmare to balance :OTheDutchess wrote:If the last class is an 'engineer', i could also imagine ranged tanking by them having to throw up stuff near the boss and tanking that way. So basically stay at range yourself, but throw up robots and stuff that are linked with you that are near the boss.
In raids i'd imagine they make sure you need at least one tank of each class. Would think the ranged tank very good at picking up adds for instance.
(as for pvp, dunno and tbh don't really care)
Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk
Our spirit is stronger than you know demon! If we are to fall, then so be it! At least now... we are free!
-Thrall, at the battle of Mount Hyjal.

-Thrall, at the battle of Mount Hyjal.

Re: A melee healing class.
It'd also be a nightmare taking all the complicated telegraphs into account.
How do you evade them while taking care of your pets at the same time?
Oh god, that's a class for our younger members... you know, the ones that still have a modicum of reflexes and reaction time!
How do you evade them while taking care of your pets at the same time?
Oh god, that's a class for our younger members... you know, the ones that still have a modicum of reflexes and reaction time!

Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 2 guests